Hey, so with the release of Hardin, I feel like my Effie just doesn't see much play anymore, I prefer my hardin in almost every single way. Because of this I wanted to fodder away my effie (+1 with berkuts lance+ and dc) to another unit. The problem is that there are soo many units I have considered and it has now become a bit ridiculous, so I'm going to make a list of what i've considered:
(note: A big part of this consideration is merge potential, therefore newer 5* only aren't being considered)
*The stats below are at +10 to get an idea on end results
1. Masked marth (48/52/38/27/21)
+ good synergy with refined weapon
+ should be expecting more merges soon
+ good mix of utility and high bst for arena (healing, green mage check)
+ +5 merges atm
- Cant inherit Berkut's lance
- Lowish res
2. Shananana (44/48/39/37/33 +def -hp BL+ def) 158 BST
+ inherit berkuts lance
+ Have a bunch of Shanna
+ 3* availability
+ Don't have any decent blue Fliers with bulk
+ good user for guidance
+ awesome defences
+good spd
+good bst
- bad att
3. Donnel (49/53/33/43/27 +def -hp BL+ def) 162 BST
+ inherit berkuts lance
+ Have a bunch of Donnel
+ 3* availability
+ High BST
+brilliant bulk
+awesome att
- acceptable spd
- res is slightly low
- already have nowi which does the same job but better
4. Lukas (54/53/23/42/28 +res -spd BL+ res) 157 BST
+ Have a bunch of Lukas
+ awesome bulk
- bad spd
- locked at 4*
- after res investment, it's still on the somewhat low end, low spd = mage doubles
- already have nowi which does the same job but better
5. Peri (41/51/40/34/34 +def-hp BL+ def) 154 BST
+ inherit berkuts lance
+ +1 merge atm
+ Decent mage counter and ok def bulk
+ Don't currently have a decent blue calv tank
- Locked at 4*
- Low BST
- Bad calv treatment from IS
Those are the main contenders, I have also given a bit of thought on units like gwen, Jagen and abel. I would love to get other peoples opinions. Finding it really hard to decide atm. Of course I could also just keep effie and try and merge her more as well, but I really don't enjoy her atm.