GamePress

Book 3 theory on Eir

Okay boyoes, I got something for yall.

EIR IS DEAD SHARENA

Firstly lets set up a timeline. The first event is Sharena's death at the start of book 3. This comes first in the timeline since it happens in the cut-scene that plays before we start Book 3. We don't meet Eir until we start book 3, when Sharena is already dead.
So from a timeline perspective, Eir being Sharena COULD happen.

Secondly, Feh doesn't say much about Eir, but she does say some interesting things about her; such as that Eir is a princess, just like Sharena.
This also solves two questions that no one is asking;
1. Why does Eir join us when she is the princess of hell?
Because if she is actually dead Sharena than of course she would join us.
2. Why is Eir, princess of death a light attribute?
Because she is actually Sharena, the light of the order of heroes.

Also her face looks the exact same, but that could be circumstantial.

Tell me what yall think down below.

Asked by Rin Core3 weeks ago

Report

Answers

I think she is a black sheep (or a white sheep tho) of this reign, so she is against the death and all those black-hearted people.

My theory is that soldier and witch are alternatives of the askr princes. They seemed to be very dark but with same hair

I didn't even notice that their hair was the same. But if that is true, than Hel would be Alfonse and Sharena's alternate mother, in which case, Eir doesn't belong. This furthers my theory on Eir being dead Sharena

I seriously doubt it. It's much more likely that she's Sharena and Alfonse's mother, judging by her visions of them smiling at her.

But she s soo young... doesnt appear to be a "mother", neither in her thirties yet.

No, she definitely looks like she could be their mother. It's in the eyes and the way she carries herself.

She couldn't be their mother since, if I recall correctly, Sharena mentions that she and her mother send each other letters due to the fact they don't get the chance to see each other often with all this Embla business

Wasnt evil Sharena shown alongside Eir? Also shoutouts to this forum correctly guessing we were gonna copy the Baldr story